Garrett County: All precincts have reported. Results are unofficial until certified. Election results
Monday, Nov. 16, 2026 A Vik Media Group publication
Deep Creek Dispatch Deep Creek Lake and mountain news: Garrett, Allegany, Mineral and Preston counties
Subscribe
Schools & Education

Garrett and Allegany 2026 school star ratings: 16 of 33 schools earned 4 stars

Card showing 16 of 33 Garrett and Allegany public schools earned 4 of 5 stars on the 2026 report card.
Graphic: Vik Media Group

Sixteen of the 33 public schools in Garrett and Allegany counties earned 4 stars out of 5 on the 2026 Maryland School Report Card, which the Maryland State Department of Education released Oct. 29, 2026. No school in either county earned 5 stars or 1 star. Two Allegany County middle schools, Washington Middle and Westmar Middle, earned 2 stars, according to the state’s school-level data file, dated Oct. 19, 2026.

Garrett County did better than the state as a whole. Seven of its 11 schools, or 64%, earned 4 stars. Statewide, 677 of 1,342 rated schools, about 50%, earned 4 or 5 stars, per MSDE’s release. In Allegany County, 9 of 22 schools earned 4 stars, 11 earned 3 and 2 earned 2.

Advertisement
Garrett and Allegany schools with 4 stars, 2026 Maryland Report Card
7 of 11Garrett County schools with 4 stars
9 of 22Allegany County schools with 4 stars
0schools with 5 stars in either county
50%Maryland schools with 4 or 5 stars
Source: MSDE, 2026 Maryland School Report Card (2026-10-29)

How does Maryland give a school its stars?

The state scores every public school on achievement, academic progress, graduation, readiness for what comes next and school quality. A school’s stars come from the percent of possible points it earned. The Maryland Report Card also gives each school a percentile rank, which compares it with Maryland schools of the same level: 50 is the middle of the state, and 93 means the school scored higher than about 93% of schools of its level.

Statewide in 2026, 134 schools earned 5 stars, 543 earned 4, 511 earned 3, 143 earned 2 and 11 earned 1 star, according to the state data.

How did each Garrett County school do?

School Stars Points earned Percentile (same level)
Accident Elementary 4 72% 81
Broad Ford Elementary 3 58% 48 (elementary), 51 (middle)
Crellin Elementary 4 73% 83
Friendsville Elementary 4 62% 50
Grantsville Elementary 4 64% 57
Northern Garrett High School 4 68% 76
Northern Middle School 4 71% 93
Route 40 Elementary 3 58% 36
Southern Garrett High School 3 57% 54 (middle), 62 (high)
Swan Meadow School 3 55% 21 (elementary), 60 (middle)
Yough Glades Elementary 4 66% 64

Source: MSDE, 2026 accountability data, school star ratings.

Northern Middle School in Accident posted the highest percentile in the two counties: 93 among Maryland middle schools. Crellin Elementary, near Oakland, and Accident Elementary ranked 83 and 81 among elementary schools.

How did each Allegany County school do?

School Stars Points earned Percentile (same level)
Cash Valley Elementary 4 71% 78
Northeast Elementary 4 69% 73
Mt. Savage Elementary 4 66% 65
Beall Elementary 4 64% 59
Frost Elementary 4 64% 60
Parkside Elementary 4 64% 58
Bel Air Elementary 4 62% 48
Cresaptown Elementary 4 62% 49
Westernport Elementary 4 62% 50
West Side Elementary 3 59% 40
Fort Hill High 3 58% 56
Mountain Ridge High School 3 58% 55
Center for Career & Technical Education 3 57% 53
Flintstone Elementary 3 57% 31
Allegany High 3 56% 49
George’s Creek Elementary 3 55% 26
John Humbird Elementary 3 53% 22
Mount Savage Middle 3 53% 49
Braddock Middle 3 49% 33
South Penn Elementary 3 45% 9
Washington Middle 2 43% 16
Westmar Middle 2 42% 15

Source: MSDE, 2026 accountability data, school star ratings.

All nine of Allegany’s 4-star schools are elementary schools. None of its four middle schools earned more than 3 stars, and its two lowest scores belong to middle schools.

Why can two schools with the same stars rank so differently?

Stars and percentiles answer different questions. South Penn Elementary in Cumberland earned 3 stars with 45% of possible points, but its percentile is 9, meaning most Maryland elementary schools scored higher. Fort Hill High also has 3 stars, with a percentile of 56. When you compare two schools, compare schools of the same level and look at both numbers.

What about Mineral and Preston schools in West Virginia?

West Virginia does not use stars. Its Balanced Scorecard scores each school and county on achievement, progress and student success. The latest release we checked is from Sept. 11, 2025, per the West Virginia Department of Education. Maryland stars and West Virginia scorecards measure different things on different scales, so a Garrett school can’t be compared with a Preston school by rating.

Where can parents see the full report card?

Each school’s page on the Maryland Report Card shows its points by category, test results, attendance and graduation rate. Questions about a specific school go to the school’s principal or the district office: Garrett County Public Schools at gcps.net and Allegany County Public Schools at acpsmd.org.

Get snow, road and breaking news alertsUrgent alerts when they happen, plus the week’s top local news on Fridays.

Free. We’ll email you once to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime.

More Real Estate guides and local services ›

Live in the Deep Creek? Write for us as a Community Contributor and share what you see in your town.

Questions and answers

What is the best-rated school in Garrett County on the 2026 Maryland Report Card?
No Garrett County school earned 5 stars in 2026. Seven earned 4 stars. Northern Middle School had the highest percentile rank, 93 among Maryland middle schools, and Crellin Elementary had the most points, 73%, per MSDE data released Oct. 29, 2026.
How many Allegany County schools earned 4 stars in 2026?
Nine of 22: Cash Valley, Northeast, Mt. Savage, Beall, Frost, Parkside, Bel Air, Cresaptown and Westernport elementary schools. Eleven schools earned 3 stars and two middle schools, Washington and Westmar, earned 2, per MSDE.
When did Maryland release the 2026 school report cards?
The Maryland State Department of Education released the 2026 Maryland School Report Card results on Oct. 29, 2026.
Can I compare a Maryland school's stars with a West Virginia school's scorecard?
No. Maryland's 1-to-5 stars and West Virginia's Balanced Scorecard use different measures and scales. Compare schools within the same state and the same level.

Sources

  1. MSDE: 2026 Maryland School Report Card results (Oct. 29, 2026) · 2026-11-02
  2. MSDE Maryland Report Card: 2026 school star ratings, data download (Oct. 19, 2026) · 2026-11-02
  3. Maryland Report Card · 2026-11-02
  4. WVDE: Balanced Scorecard 2025 · 2026-11-02
Report an error